Why Small Groups May Be the Wave of the Future: The Starfish Principle

Pastor Pete Beck III • July 1, 2020

A wonderful book entitled The Starfish and the Spider by Brafman and Beckstrom explains why centralization can make the church vulnerable to being controlled by outside forces. The early church operated from the fringes of society. It was loosely organized; although, it had clear leaders, mission, and doctrine. It possessed little or no property, power, status, or wealth. When persecuted many of its people were able to disperse, taking the gospel with them, planting new church groups all over the Roman empire. Constantine changed all that.

When the Roman government made Christianity the official  religion of the empire, the seeds of corruption and destruction were sown.

The acquisition of power, wealth, and property fundamentally altered what had been a relatively pure missional enterprise. Instead of being a marginal group that was often despised and persecuted, it became politically, financially, and socially advantageous to be part of the church. This attracted people for all the wrong reasons. Churches were no longer made up of true disciples who risked everything to be a part. They now included mere churchgoers and those trying to leverage the church for personal advantage.

Once any individual or group achieves power, wealth, and status, he or it becomes more easily manipulated and controlled. The fear of losing these things is a powerful incentive to bend to pressure.

This happened in Russia during persecution from the communist government. The Russian church was somewhat vulnerable because its structure was hierarchical and clergy dominated. They also owned many buildings and had great status. Persecutors used the threat of the loss of these things to manipulate and control. This is how it is with the spider.

All you have to do to kill a spider is step on its head.

The Chinese church, on the other hand, had a history and culture of small groups. It held little or no land and had no hierarchy or status. When persecution arose in that nation, the church went underground, meeting in homes. If one leader was struck down, another arose. Everyone was expected to become a church planter and raise up his or her own small group.

This is the starfish principle. You can break off a piece of a starfish, and it will regenerate into another animal. It’s much more difficult to kill one. Decentralized small groups are very effective in places where persecution exists.

Nik Ripken, a pseudonym, in his book The Insanity of Obedience , explains why.

Furthermore, buildings are not necessary; in fact, usually buildings are seen as a hindrance. Constructing buildings requires too much time and money. Buildings are dangerous because they allow the persecutors to locate most of the believers at a set place and at a set time. In a sense, buildings become a kind of “one-stop shopping” for those opposed to Jesus, His gospel, and His followers. [p.125.]

If severe persecution comes to America, underground small groups will be the most effective way to go forward as a church. Right now it has been too easy and convenient to use buildings to gather large crowds, but that day may be coming to an end.

By Pete Beck III February 10, 2025
Following Christ is not a spectator sport. Each of us has a role to play and a job to do.
By Pete Beck III December 18, 2024
Bitterness imprisons its victims and subjects them to demonic harassment, a version of self-inflicted torture.
By Pete Beck III December 17, 2024
One of the most difficult and challenging times is when we are not sure of what to do next.
By Pete Beck III December 13, 2024
When the gospel accomplishes its purpose in us, it brings glory to our Lord and a sense of peace and contentment to us, while it furthers the advance of God’s kingdom.
By Pete Beck III December 12, 2024
Our heavenly Father has great interest in our lives and shows his children what he wants us to do.
By Pete Beck III December 3, 2024
Christianity is not a spectator sport. The Reformation renewed some very important truths of the faith that had been lost over time, one of which is the priesthood of the believer . This doctrine means that in the New Covenant there is no clergy-laity distinction. Everyone is called to ministry. All followers of Christ are called, equipped, and expected to partner with the Holy Spirit in the adventure of using their spiritual gifts, time, energy, finances – everything – to fish for people and encourage them to become followers of Christ and fishers of men in their own right. Every football and basketball season an interesting phenomenon takes place. People personally identify with their favorite teams. When their team is doing well, they feel good about themselves and become enthusiastic, vocal, and visible fans. What is so intriguing is that many of us think that we somehow acquire greater worth and prestige, if our team excels and does better than the other teams. It is almost as if we were the ones who are competing. All big sporting events are filled with such fans who get satisfaction out of watching others play the game. So it is with many people who attend churches. We all know that playing and spectating are vastly different. When we spectate, we can imagine ourselves making better decisions and better plays than the players on the court or the field, but the reality is that we are not playing. Jesus has invited his followers actually to participate in the greatest adventure of being his Spirit-filled and empowered representatives. Unfortunately most of us who call ourselves Christians are merely spectating fans. We may agree with the concept of being involved in the Great Commission, but we have fallen into the trap of being passive, sitting on the sidelines, hoping that someone else will lead our family member, neighbor, or friend to Christ and teach them how to follow him fully. Many Christians think that evangelism is inviting someone to church, where they will hear the preacher talk about Christ. We do not see ourselves as the one who can best share the gospel with them. However, the truth of the matter is that we cannot transfer our responsibility to fulfill the Great Commission to someone else. God does not give us the option of merely being fans or spectators. God asks us to be players – disciples and disciple makers. Not everyone is equally gifted in this area, but we are all asked to participate. Some may win thousands to Christ, while others may help only a few become followers of the Master over a lifetime. Sadly, a great number of those who call themselves Christians have never led even one person to faith in Christ. In some cases they have given up trying. This ought not be. Could this be because we do not even talk about Jesus in a serious way with anyone outside of church meetings? Suggestions Ask God to forgive us for succumbing to laziness, fear, and the spirit of the age that tells us to keep our faith to ourselves. Ask the Holy Spirit to stir in us the fire of enthusiasm for Jesus and the Gospel. Ask him to give us a love for those who live around you who do not yet know Christ. Familiarize ourselves with the Gospel. (I recommend The King Jesus Gospel by McKnight. You can read my summary by clicking here or you may wish to read my articles on the subject .) Pray for opportunities to speak meaningfully to people. Make it a priority to get to know the people in your neighborhood, at work, at the gym, at school, and wherever you have the opportunity to connect. As we spend time in conversation, we will begin to see how Jesus and the Gospel can help them. Our care for them may give us a platform from which to speak about Jesus to them. Visit people and have them over to our homes. The more time we spend with people, the greater the opportunity we provide for the Holy Spirit to work in the relationships. Offer to pray for people on the spot when a genuine need for God’s help surfaces. Join a group (or start one) whose focus is fishing for people and making disciples. In many cases this will be what some call a “missional” church, as opposed to an event-oriented spectator church. We need to be encouraged in the work of the Great Commission because, although it is rewarding, it can be difficult and discouraging at times. Never, never, never, never give up. Our heavenly reward will be great!
Show More
Share by: